Red type indicates Lou Gehrig Award Winners that have signed on as supporters
| Year | Player | Team | Current Team |
| 2020 | Stephen Piscotty | Oakland A’s | Oakland A’s |
| 2019 | Buster Posey | San Francisco Giants | Retired |
| 2018 | Corey Kluber | Cleveland Indians | New York Yankees |
| 2017 | Joey Votto | Cincinnati Reds | Cincinnati Reds |
| 2016 | José Altuve | Houston Astros | Houston Astros |
| 2015 | Curtis Granderson | New York Mets | Retired |
| 2014 | Adrián Beltré | Texas Rangers | Retired |
| 2013 | Josh Hamilton | Los Angeles Angels | Retired |
| 2012 | Barry Zito | San Francisco Giants | Retired |
| 2011 | Ryan Zimmerman | Washington Nationals | Retired |
| 2010 | Derek Jeter | New York Yankees | Retired |
| 2009 | Albert Pujols | St. Louis Cardinals | Retired |
| 2008 | Shane Victorino | Philadelphia Phillies | Retired |
| 2007 | Mike Timlin | Boston Red Sox | Retired |
| 2006 | Trevor Hoffman | San Diego Padres | Retired |
| 2005 | John Smoltz | Atlanta Braves | Retired |
| 2004 | Jim Thome | Philadelphia Phillies | Retired |
| 2003 | Jamie Moyer | Seattle Mariners | Retired |
| 2002 | Danny Graves | Cincinnati Reds | Retired |
| 2001 | John Franco | New York Mets | Retired |
| 2000 | Todd Stottlemyre | Arizona Diamondbacks | Retired |
| 1999 | Mark McGwire | St. Louis Cardinals | Retired |
| 1998 | Tony Gwynn | San Diego Padres | Deceased |
| 1997 | Paul Molitor | Minnesota Twins | Retired |
| 1996 | Brett Butler | Los Angeles Dodgers | Retired |
| 1995 | Curt Schilling | Philadelphia Phillies | Retired |
| 1994 | Barry Larkin | Cincinnati Reds | Retired |
| 1993 | Don Mattingly | New York Yankees | Miami Marlins |
| 1992 | Cal Ripken, Jr. | Baltimore Orioles | Retired |
| 1991 | Kent Hrbek | Minnesota Twins | Retired |
| 1990 | Glenn Davis | Houston Astros | Retired |
| 1989 | Ozzie Smith | St. Louis Cardinals | Retired |
| 1988 | Buddy Bell | Houston Astros | Retired |
| 1987 | Rick Sutcliffe | Chicago Cubs | Retired |
| 1986 | George Brett | Kansas City Royals | Retired |
| 1985 | Dale Murphy | Atlanta Braves | Retired |
| 1984 | Steve Garvey | San Diego Padres | Retired |
| 1983 | Mike Schmidt | Philadelphia Phillies | Retired |
| 1982 | Ron Cey | Los Angeles Dodgers | Retired |
| 1981 | Tommy John | New York Yankees | Retired |
| 1980 | Tony Pérez | Boston Red Sox | Retired |
| 1979 | Phil Niekro | Atlanta Braves | Deceased |
| 1978 | Don Kessinger | Chicago White Sox | Retired |
| 1977 | Lou Brock | St. Louis Cardinals | Deceased |
| 1976 | Don Sutton | Los Angeles Dodgers | Retired |
| 1975 | Johnny Bench | Cincinnati Reds | Retired |
| 1974 | Willie Stargell | Pittsburgh Pirates | Deceased |
| 1973 | Ron Santo | Chicago Cubs | Deceased |
| 1972 | Wes Parker | Los Angeles Dodgers | Retired |
| 1971 | Harmon Killebrew | Minnesota Twins | Deceased |
| 1970 | Hank Aaron | Atlanta Braves | Deceased |
| 1969 | Pete Rose | Cincinnati Reds | Retired |
| 1968 | Al Kaline | Detroit Tigers | Deceased |
| 1967 | Ernie Banks | Chicago Cubs | Deceased |
| 1966 | Brooks Robinson | Baltimore Orioles | Retired |
| 1965 | Vern Law | Pittsburgh Pirates | Retired |
| 1964 | Ken Boyer | St. Louis Cardinals | Deceased |
| 1963 | Bobby Richardson | New York Yankees | Retired |
| 1962 | Robin Roberts | Baltimore Orioles | Deceased |
| 1961 | Warren Spahn | Milwaukee Braves | Deceased |
| 1960 | Dick Groat | Pittsburgh Pirates | Retired |
| 1959 | Gil Hodges | Los Angeles Dodgers | Deceased |
| 1958 | Gil McDougald | New York Yankees | Deceased |
| 1957 | Stan Musial | St. Louis Cardinals | Deceased |
| 1956 | Pee Wee Reese | Brooklyn Dodgers | Deceased |
| 1955 | Alvin Dark | New York Giants | Deceased |